I’ve been using the Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro for about two weeks now. I wanted to give my opinions time to mature, but my impressions from the first hour using it have only been confirmed with further use. This accessory is a game changer, and it’s made using my iPad more fun.
The Magic Keyboard costs $300 or $350, depending on which size iPad you have, which is a lot for a keyboard case. However, it’s a pretty damn good keyboard case. The design quality is terrific: while it is a bit heavy, it’s remarkably sturdy and the magnets that attach the iPad are almost unbelievably strong. The keyboard itself is nice, but I do find myself hitting the wrong keys more frequently than I do on my Mac, for some reason. The Magic Keyboard’s trackpad is a delight to use, and the way Apple has implemented cursor support on the iPad makes it clear that they spent a lot of time thinking about how to do it well.
For a long time, Apple has been positioning the iPad (especially the iPad Pro line) as a laptop replacement, but the iPad hasn’t really been good enough at computer-y things for me to recommend people buy one for that purpose. The Magic Keyboard doesn’t fix all of the problems it has, but it gets the iPad a lot closer to truly being a viable laptop replacement. Before this accessory, I might’ve suggested that 5-10% of people should get an iPad instead of a laptop as their next daily driver, among them would be children under 12, old people, and those whose computer use and general tech know how maxes out around email and social media. With the Magic Keyboard, that number of folks I’d recommend an iPad for jumps to around 40%. It’s still not great for everyone as a primary machine, and there are a lot of things that the iPad can do that are still just better on a Mac, but for a new chunk of people, I think this could be a good fit.
Of course, after you consider the price of an iPad Pro plus the Magic Keyboard (the 11” setup costs $1100 and the 12.9” setup costs $1350), you’re well within range of a MacBook Air, so it’s a difficult argument to make. But the iPad does have a few advantages: a MacBook Air can’t separate its display from its base, you can’t interact with the display via touch, and the Apple Pencil (sold separately for an additional $130) is a great tool for creatives. However, Macs have their own advantages, from longer battery life to a more mature and capable operating system. For example, if you wanted to crank up a professional photo editing app and touch up a photo on a MacBook Air, it may be a little slow, but you could do it. On an iPad, you’ll be hamstrung by the availability of good photo editing apps and their less robust, touch-first UI design.
In any case, the point of this article isn’t to serve as an assessment whether the iPad can finally replace your laptop, because that metric is different for everyone. The point of this article is to say that the Magic Keyboard is a terrific product (even though it’s one for which Apple charges a particularly high price), and everything about it is better than its competition. If you think you’d like an iPad with a keyboard, you’ll love the Magic Keyboard.