I went into “Red (Taylor’s Version)” with a pretty sour attitude, and I want to address that first, because while my opinions have since changed and I’m now very pleased with the album, I still think my frustrations at the time were valid. I posted the following on Reddit the week before the album was released:
Is anyone else feeling a bit down on Red (TV)? I’m a huge fan, don’t get me wrong, but the lack of promo material for this album has me feeling ambivalent about it, and at times even resentful.
She first told us about the album five months ago, and I just think that’s a lot time to let us sit on the knowledge that it’s coming, but to keep us wondering the whole time if could finally be the day we get a single or a vault track or something. The fact that the album comes out a week from today and we still haven’t gotten ANYTHING is really frustrating to me, and it’s souring me on the album as a whole. It feels like Taylor is taking advantage of our dedication and our excitement by keeping us all anxious and waiting, but never giving us more than a 10 second scrap of a song.
Red was one of the re-records that I was most excited for, but now I’m just feeling a bit aggravated at the thought of it. I feel like we deserve at least one single to help us get in the mood for it, especially given that Fearless (TV) gave us 3 singles (with two of them being vault tracks) across a much shorter time frame.
I recognize that this probably isn’t the general sentiment right now because most people ARE excited, and I know Taylor doesn’t owe us anything, I’m just curious if anyone else is feeling the same way.
I was excited for the first single to drop so we could get a taste of what the next chapter in the Taylor’s Version story would sound like, to begin comparing and contrasting with how “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” sounded. Unfortunately, weeks and months were passing with no singles ever being released, and really no other promotional material to help get me excited about the rerelease. Even though Taylor promoted her version of “Red” heavily following its release, I still think my points stand.
Anyway, once the album finally came out, I really enjoyed it. So, without further adieu:
My Notes
As with my “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” review, I won’t go song by song for the entire album since most of them aren’t original, but here are my more general thoughts and some specific points I wanted to make.
The album sounds really good. Her voice is, again, noticeably more mature. The production on most of these songs is as good as ever, and I actually think it’s better in more than a few cases. However, there are a few songs where I don’t think they were improved, and they sound a little too different from the originals for my taste, and that’s particularly true of some of the louder, more upbeat songs like “I Knew You Were Trouble,” “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,” and “22.” They just sounded a bit hollow to me the first few times I listened to them. Taylor’s voice is front and center, but it sounds like the instruments were positioned about 20 feet behind her when it was recorded. They lack bass and they aren’t punchy enough. However, listening to these songs in Spatial Audio does improve the experience significantly. It no longer sounds like the instruments are far away, instead it’s as if you’re inside the song and the instruments are all around you (though they still aren’t quite loud enough). It gives me the impression that these songs were recreated with Spatial Audio in mind, and tuned specifically for that format to the detriment of the stereo listening experience. Even taking that into account, those more upbeat songs still aren’t produced as well as the originals, and they just needed to sound a little fuller.
While we’re talking about how the songs sound, “Girl At Home” is an interesting case study. On the original album, it was arguably my least favorite song. Frankly, it’s sonically boring, and the lyrics come across as a little high and mighty to me. That said, in the interest of having the most faithful rerecords possible, I don’t like how much she changed it. It doesn’t sound much like the original at all, and while I must admit that I like the new version better and find it significantly more enjoyable, the idea that she’s willing to change songs that much scares me. I don’t like her setting the precedent that the original sounds of some of her less popular songs aren’t off the chopping block; it would really upset me if she changed a song like “I Wish You Would” or something else that was a lesser known track from its album, but now I’m afraid that’s a possibility. “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” was a more faithful recreation than “Red (Taylor’s Version),” and it made me feel really good about the prospects of everyone getting their favorite songs recreated in a way that was faithful to the originals, even if your favorite wasn’t everyone else's favorite. “Girl At Home” is causing that fear to creep back in a bit.
On a different note, I was really stoked that she got Gary Lightbody back for “The Last Time.” That was the song with a featured artist I was most excited to hear recreated, and also the one where I thought it was most uncertain whether the featured artist would return, so I’m really glad she got him back, and the song sounds great. It’s always been one of my favorites from “Red.”
I was worried that the vault songs on this album wouldn’t be terribly impressive, both because there were so many of them, and because most of the Vault songs from Fearless weren’t terribly impressive. However, the “Red” Vault did not disappoint. There were some songs we’d heard before, and they were more or less what we were expecting, but the new songs were all more capable of holding their own that the “Fearless” Vault tracks. I could envision an alternate history where any of those songs had made it on the original album.
The Vault, Song by Song:
As usual, I’ve given each song two ratings out of ten, the first rating is how I felt about it after the first time I listened to it, the second is how I feel about it after more listens and some time to process each track.
“Ronan (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 4.5/10, 2/10
I don’t like anything about this track. It’s slow, depressing, and nothing about it is musically impressive. Most of the lyrics don’t even rhyme. Yeah, yeah, I’m an asshole. We know.
“Better Man (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 9.5/10, 9/10
It takes a little getting used to just because it’s not what we’re used to, but I love it. It’s crazy that her original “Better Man” demo from 2012 leaked right before the album came out, but I liked it, and I liked that this was very similar to it.
“Nothing New (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault) [feat. Phoebe Bridgers]”: 6.5/10, 5/10
This song would’ve made a lot more sense if it’d come out in 2012. Also, one of my friends pointed out that the duet could’ve been better if they were having more of a conversation between someone at the start of their career and someone well established, rather saying almost the exact same things, as if they were both fledgling celebrities.
“Babe (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 7/10, 6.5/10
The “promises promises” part was unexpected and less than needed, but I still like the song. Like “Better Man,” it does take some getting used to.
“Message In A Bottle (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 6.5/10, 6.5/10
This one is very poppy. It’s a bit more early 2000s bubblegum pop though, and I’m glad that her pop style evolved in the direction of 1989 rather than having gone this way. That said, I do like the song.
“I Bet You Think About Me (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault) [feat. Chris Stapleton]”: 8.5/10, 7/10
She sounds like a pirate at the beginning. Other than that, I like the song. It clearly ties in with “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,” (see: “do you have all the space that you need”), and I think it fits the “Red” vibe pretty well. I don’t see why Chris Stapleton is here though. Did he also get left by a boy who thought he was better than him? Probably not, and he doesn’t really add anything to the song.
“Forever Winter (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 6.5/10, 7/10
I liked this one a lot. I expected it to be the “rip your heart out and stomp on it” song, but none of the new vault tracks really were that (I think she saved it all for ATW10, which is fine). I think this track is a good commentary on men’s mental health, which doesn’t get talked about nearly enough. The man in the song is clearly dealing with some mental health issues, and the girl is slow to recognize it and clueless as to how to fix it. It’s from her perspective, but it’s 100% about him.
“Run (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault) [feat. Ed Sheeran]”: 6/10, 7/10
I liked this one a little more than I expected to. I think the fact that it didn’t make the album original led to it being repurposed and turned into “I Know Places.”
“The Very First Night (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 7/10, 6/10
This one is good, but a little forgettable despite being very catchy. People have been trying to out Taylor as a lesbian forever, and I don’t buy that at all, but someone pointed out to me that the lines “didn’t read the note on the Polaroid picture” and “no one knows about the words that we whispered” are followed by lines that go “do you know how much I miss you” and “they don’t know how much I miss you,” and in both cases, the line “how much I miss her” would’ve rhymed perfectly. Probably a coincidence, but interesting nonetheless. And “miss her” rhymes so much better that I often sing it wrong.
“All Too Well (Ten Minute Version) (Taylor’s Version) (From The Vault)”: 7.5/10, 9/10
Ah, where to begin? I guess the beginning is the best place: right from the start, you know that this is not the “All Too Well” we’re used to. It’s a little slower, but the whammy bar in those first few measures is a little hypnotic and I think it sounded great. Following that, it took a little longer than I expected for us to start hearing some of the added lyrics. When they finally do come in, they take you by surprise: one of the first added lines is “fuck the patriarchy.” This really put my guard up. I was not expecting Taylor to come out swinging with some political message in her most beloved and most anticipated song ever. After a few listens, and a few conversations with friends who were also taken aback, you piece together that she’s talking about the “keychain on the ground,” which we’re to presume had the words “fuck the patriarchy” on it. This makes more sense and is a lot less random, and it also makes it somewhat plausible that this line was from the original version of the song, but still, the way the line is delivered makes it sounded pointed and modern, almost disconnected from the lyrics that come before and after it. Maybe Jake Gyllenhaal really had a keychain that said that, but it’s hard to know, and the line certainly does play well with Taylor’s liberal fanbase today.
Next: the best lyric in the song. I have no idea why she wouldn’t have put this in the original. “You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath” is an absolutely devastating piece of lyrical genius. Honorable mention to “they say all’s well that ends well/but I’m in a new hell every time/you double cross my mind.”
This part isn’t as impressive from a lyrical perspective, but her voice is really powerful and I love the part where she sings about her dad telling her “it’s supposed to be fun, turning 21” as she sits at her own party upset about her boyfriend who didn’t show up.
There are two times where the sound of the song shifts so dramatically that it almost sounds like a separate song entirely. The first of those is when she sings “And I was never good at telling jokes.” You aren’t exactly sure where it’s going, but it fits the vibe of the rest of the song, if not the sound.
The second time when the sound of the song shifts is when she sings about the snow “and how it glistened as it fell.” The last two minutes of the song are really slow. It feels like this maybe should’ve been “All Too Well (Eight Minute Version)” but she had to live up to ten after nearly a decade of rumors, so she stretched it out a little bit. I know some people think the extra time to wind down is good after such an emotional song, but I think I would’ve liked it better if it went out with the same energy as 2012 Taylor screaming “broke me like a promise,” even if it needed to be a little shorter to make it work.
Overall, I really love this track, and it is now the only version of All Too Well that I listen to. It isn’t perfect, but I think there’s enough here that’s great that is has replaced the original for me.
Final Thoughts
This album is really good, but it’s not as faithful a recreation of its source material as Fearless (Taylor’s Version). I hope Red (Taylor’s Version) is the outlier and not Fearless (Taylor’s Version).
That said, I hope that “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” is the outlier when it comes to vault tracks, because “Red” knocked it out of the park. Granted, having ATW10 is an unfair advantage, but the rest of the vault tracks were all solid, and the same can’t be said for “Fearless.” I still think she could have some great stuff up her sleeve, and I’m especially excited for the vault tracks from “1989” and “Reputation.”
I’ll get skewered by the Swiftie mob for this, but Red (Stolen Version) was never my favorite Taylor album, and it still isn’t. Right after the rerecord was announced, I had thought that it may give me the opportunity to appreciate this album on a deeper level than I had before, and allow me to connect with it in that almost spiritual way that some Swift fans do. Unfortunately, that didn’t happen. I still think it’s a great album, I respect the hell out of it, and I’ve loved having this opportunity to experience it, but the lack of promo before the release did take its toll, as well as the issue of it not being quite as sonically similar to the original, with some of the most popular songs sounding slightly hollow. I hope that this turns out to be the worst of the rerecorded albums, for me. But I am genuinely happy for the fans for whom this will be the best rerecord, because even if they don’t think it’s perfect, I know how much this album means to people and I’m glad they’re getting to re-experience it like this.
I will say though, l hope that with the next Taylor’s Version album, she doesn’t announce it until she’s a little closer to its release date, or that she at least gives us a single or two to get us through. I think a lot of my more negative opinions were shaped by my early disappointment.